Subclass 482 Visa: Why a Genuine Position Matters for Employers

Introduction

Having a genuine need for a skilled worker does not automatically mean an employer-sponsored nomination will be approved. Employers need to show how the position fits their business operations and why the role is necessary.

An Australian business had secured major construction projects and needed an experienced supervisor to coordinate work across multiple sites. The business nominated a worker who had already been performing similar duties as a subcontractor. But the Department of Immigration refused the nomination because it was not satisfied the position was genuine.

The employer challenged the decision. The Migration Review Tribunal overturned the refusal and approved the nomination.

The case highlights an important lesson for Australian employers considering the 482 Skills In Demand. A business must do more than show it needs workers. It must provide evidence of the nominated position, explain why the role is necessary and demonstrate how the worker’s duties align with the nominated occupation.

The Challenge

The Department questioned whether the nominated position was consistent with the core nature of the business. Although the company had substantial contracts and ongoing projects, the initial evidence did not satisfy the Department that the position was genuine.

The employer needed to establish several key points.

The business required a supervisor to oversee construction work and coordinate installation activities across multiple sites. The proposed worker had relevant industry experience and had already performed similar duties as a subcontractor.

The employer also needed to demonstrate the company’s financial position, explain its staffing arrangements and show how the proposed role fitted into its operations.

Our Solution

The Tribunal reviewed the evidence submitted by the employer, including project records, financial statements, invoices, an organisational chart, emails, a Safe Work Method Statement and photographs of the worker performing duties at construction sites.

The evidence helped establish the connection between the company’s operations and the nominated position.

Three factors were particularly important.

  1. Demonstrating a genuine business need

The employer explained the scale and nature of its construction projects. The Tribunal accepted that the business needed a supervisor to oversee installation work, inspect worksites, coordinate tradespeople and manage activities involving contractors.

  1. Connecting the duties to the nominated occupation

The employer provided details of the worker’s responsibilities and supporting workplace evidence. The Tribunal found that the duties substantially aligned with the nominated Building Associate occupation under ANZSCO 312112.

  1. Establishing the worker’s relevant experience and employment arrangements

The worker had experience in the construction industry and had performed similar duties for the business as a subcontractor. The employer also provided an employment contract setting out the proposed full-time arrangement and remuneration.

The Tribunal considered the evidence as a whole and found that the nominated position was genuine and that the applicable nomination requirements had been met.

The Result

The Tribunal set aside the Department’s refusal and substituted a decision approving the nomination.

The outcome demonstrates the importance of presenting clear, consistent evidence when an employer’s need for a nominated position is questioned.

How Solve Migration Can Help

A strong employer sponsored visa application starts with a clear understanding of the business, the position and the worker’s suitability.

Solve Migration assists employers with assessing nomination requirements, preparing supporting documentation and identifying potential issues before an application is lodged. The right preparation helps employers present a clear and consistent account of why the position is needed and how the proposed worker meets the relevant requirements.

Before lodging a Subclass 482 nomination, make sure your business can clearly explain the role, its operational need and the evidence supporting it.

Book a consultation with Solve Migration to discuss your business’s circumstances and understand the relevant sponsorship requirements.

https://solvemigration.com/book-an-appointment/

Email: ask@solvemigration.com

Book an appointment