Turning a Visa Nomination Refusal into Approval: The Sheetmetal Trades Worker Case

Introduction

When an employer nominates a skilled worker for an employer-sponsored visa, the Department assesses whether the position is genuine and whether the business can support the role.

In one case, the Department refused a nomination for a Sheetmetal Trades Worker. It questioned whether the proposed position reflected a genuine business need and whether the employer’s financial circumstances supported the role.

The employer challenged the refusal. After reviewing the business operations, job duties, nominee’s experience, employment terms, salary evidence and recruitment records, the Tribunal overturned the refusal and approved the nomination.

The case highlights the importance of presenting clear, consistent evidence that connects the nominated occupation to the employer’s real business activities.

The Challenge

The employer operated a ductwork supply and installation business. It supplied and installed ductwork for commercial, industrial and residential projects, with a focus on air-handling systems in multi-storey buildings.

The business nominated a worker for Sheetmetal Trades Worker (ANZSCO 322211) under the Subclass 482 visa pathway. The Department refused the nomination because it was not satisfied that the position was genuine. It also questioned whether the business could financially support the role and whether its operations matched the nominated position.

The Tribunal therefore examined the actual duties, the employer’s operations and financial records, the nominee’s experience and qualifications, and the terms of employment.

The Evidence

The Job Duties Matched Sheetmetal Work

The employer submitted a position description and compared the duties with the tasks listed for Sheetmetal Trades Worker in ANZSCO.

The role involved studying plans and specifications for ventilation and ductwork installations, selecting and inspecting metal materials, measuring ductwork, and cutting, bending, shaping and joining sheet metal. The worker also used machinery to complete assigned work, coordinated installation-related shutdowns and start-ups, travelled to project sites and made modifications when needed.

The duty comparison allocated time across key tasks, including planning and reviewing blueprints, selecting materials, measuring dimensions, cutting and shaping metal, and carrying out related fabrication or installation work. The Tribunal considered the comparison alongside oral evidence and supporting documents.

After assessing the duties against the nominated occupation, the Tribunal accepted that the position was genuine and that the role was full-time.

The Employer Explained the Business Need

The nominee had previously worked with the business as a subcontractor. The Tribunal asked why the employer now wanted to employ the worker directly rather than continue the subcontracting arrangement.

The employer explained that the construction industry often relies on subcontractors because it can be difficult to find skilled and reliable workers willing to work for one employer. As the business grew, it wanted to employ skilled workers directly through sponsorship. The Tribunal considered this explanation alongside the business’s size, activities and staffing needs.

The Tribunal also reviewed the nominee’s qualifications and experience, the employment contract, the history of subcontractor payments, tax returns, financial statements and Business Activity Statements. It accepted that the business had a genuine need for the position.

Salary and Employment Records Supported the Nomination

The employer provided a written employment contract offering annual earnings of AUD 90,000, plus superannuation. It also supplied the relevant industrial award and salary information from job advertisements and industry salary surveys.

The Tribunal reviewed salary information from Indeed, Job Outlook and SalaryExpert. The material showed a range of salaries for comparable sheetmetal work. The Tribunal accepted that the employer had determined the market salary rate appropriately and that the proposed earnings met the applicable criteria for this nomination.

The Tribunal also considered the employment terms and found them consistent with the evidence before it, including the relevant employment-law requirements.

Recruitment Evidence Met Labour Market Testing Requirements

The employer advertised the position on Jora and JobActive. The advertisements appeared in English, identified the employer and included a salary range of AUD 80,000 to AUD 100,000 per year.

The recruitment process ran for more than four weeks and generated two responses. The employer also stated that it had not made employees in the nominated occupation redundant or retrenched them during the relevant four-month period.

The Tribunal accepted that the employer met the labour market testing requirements and that no suitably qualified and experienced Australian worker or eligible temporary visa holder was readily available to fill the position.

The Result

The Tribunal set aside the refusal and substituted a decision approving the nomination.

It accepted that the position was genuine and full-time. It also found that the employment contract, salary evidence, business records and labour market testing satisfied the applicable nomination criteria.

The decision demonstrates why employers should explain the business need for a role and support that explanation with consistent evidence. A clear duty comparison, financial records, salary benchmarks, employment documents and recruitment records can help decision-makers understand how a nominated position fits the business.

Book an appointment