Beyond the Refusal: How Persistence and Evidence Led to a Positive Outcome

Introduction

An Australian business wanted to retain an experienced employee in a specialised project administration role. However, the Department refused its employer nomination because the business had not demonstrated sufficient financial capacity to support the position.

The refusal also affected the employee’s related visa application, creating uncertainty for both the employer and the worker. This case highlights an important lesson for businesses sponsoring overseas employees: strong applications need clear, relevant evidence.

The Challenge: Proving Financial Capacity

The employer’s original nomination application lacked supporting documents to demonstrate its ability to employ the nominated worker for the required period.

Without this evidence, the Department could not establish that the business met the relevant employment requirements. Although the company continued operating, its application did not adequately demonstrate its financial position or capacity to sustain the role.

Our Solution: Strengthening the Evidence

During the Tribunal review, the employer submitted additional documents to address concerns about its financial capacity and business operations.

These documents included financial statements, Business Activity Statements (BAS), company tax returns, accountant letters, employment records and other relevant information.

The Tribunal examined the company’s financial performance, including its increased turnover and improved profitability. It also considered the employee’s established employment history.

Together, these records helped demonstrate that the business could continue employing the worker at the nominated salary.

The Result: A Positive Outcome

The Tribunal set aside the refusal and approved the employer nomination.

This outcome demonstrated how a stronger evidentiary record can help address concerns that lead to a nomination refusal. It also reinforced the importance of preparing a complete application and supporting claims with relevant documentation.

Every case presents different circumstances, and no outcome is guaranteed. Employers should carefully prepare their applications and seek professional guidance when they encounter complex sponsorship issues.

 

Is your business preparing an employer-sponsored visa application, or have you received a nomination refusal?

Solve Migration can help you understand your circumstances and explore the options available to you.

Book a Consultation – https://solvemigration.com/book-an-appointment/

Contact Us – ask@solvemigration.com

Book an appointment