Why Was This Employer Nomination Refused and How Was It Overturned?

Introduction

An Australian regional business wanted to sponsor a Retail Manager to support its growing operations. However, the Department refused its employer nomination because it questioned whether the position’s duties matched the nominated occupation.

The business challenged the decision at the tribunal and presented evidence to demonstrate that the role met the relevant requirements.

The Challenge: Proving the Role Was Genuine

Danta Petroleum Pty Ltd sought to nominate a Retail Manager (General) under ANZSCO 142111. The Department refused the nomination in January 2018 because it was not satisfied that the position’s duties aligned with the nominated occupation.

The business needed to demonstrate that the nominee performed genuine managerial duties beyond simply supervising retail workers. It also had to establish the business’s need for the position and support its claims with relevant documentation.

Our Solution: Building a Strong Evidence Base

During the tribunal review, the employer submitted employment contracts, financial records, a position description and evidence of the nominee’s actual responsibilities.

These responsibilities included managing budgets, monitoring stock, overseeing staff, maintaining financial records and ensuring workplace health and safety compliance.

The employer also provided recruitment evidence detailing 18 applicants and explaining why it considered them unsuitable for the position.

This evidence showed that the nominee managed the service station’s daily operations and handled broader responsibilities involving marketing, staffing and operational performance. The Tribunal compared these duties with the expectations for a Retail Manager (General) and assessed whether the business genuinely needed the position.

The Result: The Tribunal Approved the Nomination

On 6 April 2021, the Tribunal set aside the Department’s refusal and substituted a decision approving the nomination.

The Tribunal accepted that the nominee’s duties aligned with the nominated occupation. It also found that the business genuinely needed the position and met the relevant requirements for the regional nomination.

This case demonstrates why employers should provide clear, consistent evidence of an employee’s actual duties and the business’s operational needs when preparing an employer nomination.

What Employers Can Learn

A job title alone may not establish that a position meets the requirements for a nominated occupation. Employers should ensure that their position descriptions, employment records and supporting documents accurately reflect the work the employee performs.

Every application depends on its individual circumstances and the applicable requirements. A successful outcome in one tribunal case does not guarantee the same result in another.

Need Help With Employer Sponsorship?

If your business plans to sponsor an overseas worker or needs assistance with an employer nomination, contact Solve Migration to discuss your circumstances with a registered migration agent.

Book a Consultation: https://solvemigration.com/book-an-appointment/

Contact Us: ask@solvemigration.com

Book an appointment