A Career Built on Care, A Nomination Worth Fighting For

 

The Dream

A healthcare worker with years of experience caring for elderly people and people with disabilities in Sydney faced a major setback when the Department refused his employer’s nomination. The central issue was whether the nominated position was genuine. His work involved preparing care plans, supporting clients with behavioural issues, preparing progress reports, assisting with daily activities and working closely with care providers and government organisations.

He wanted to continue working in the healthcare industry and use his experience to support people who needed care. His company was established to provide healthcare services and engage him as a Residential Care Officer.

The business nominated him for a Subclass 482 Skills in Demand visa under the occupation Residential Care Officer, ANZSCO 411715. The role involved caring for and supervising elderly and disabled clients and supporting their individual needs.

The Problem

The Department refused the nomination.

The main concern was whether the nominated position was genuine. Under the current nomination framework, the Minister must be satisfied that the position associated with the nominated occupation is genuine.

For the business, this created a serious problem. The company had been operating in the healthcare sector, and the nominee had already developed substantial experience providing care services in Sydney.

The applicant therefore needed to demonstrate that the nominated position reflected genuine business activities and that the nominee’s duties were consistent with the nominated occupation.

The Evidence

The matter proceeded to the Tribunal.
During the hearing, the Tribunal examined the nominee’s background, qualifications, employment history, duties and day-to-day work.

The evidence showed that the nominee had previous experience working as a Residential Care Officer in London. He had also obtained a Certificate III in childcare and disability care and had experience working with elderly people and implementing care programs.

His Australian work involved caring for elderly and disabled clients, including people with autism and behavioural difficulties. His responsibilities included preparing and implementing care plans, managing behavioural issues, preparing progress reports, administering medication, communicating with care organisations, and liaising with police, courts, ambulance services and government organisations when required.

He also worked with teenagers, including taking them to school, communicating with teachers and supervising them during overnight shifts.

Independent evidence also supported the nomination. A witness who had worked with the nominee for several years described his work with an autistic young person and confirmed his involvement in developing care plans, monitoring behaviour and helping the client develop greater independence. The witness also described his ability to communicate effectively with the client and manage challenging behaviour.

The Solution

The Tribunal considered the evidence as a whole.

It examined whether the nomination satisfied the applicable requirements. The Tribunal found that the applicant was a standard business sponsor and had correctly identified the nominee and the nominated occupation.

The Tribunal also considered the employment conditions. The employment contract provided a base salary of $67,500 per year, exclusive of superannuation. The Tribunal found that the terms and conditions were no less favourable than those applicable to the relevant Australian equivalent.

The Tribunal then considered the central issue: whether the nominated position was genuine.

The Tribunal found that the nominee was performing a majority of the duties associated with Residential Care Officer under ANZSCO. His background and work history were supported by an independent witness who had observed him performing the role for approximately three years.

The positive VETASSESS skills assessment also supported his experience in the nominated occupation.

The Tribunal also considered the applicant’s recruitment efforts. The position had been advertised online and the applicant received no responses. The Tribunal accepted the evidence regarding the recruitment efforts and found that the applicable labour market testing requirements had been satisfied.

The Outcome

The Tribunal set aside the Department’s decision not to approve the nomination.

The Tribunal substituted a decision approving the nomination.

The Tribunal found that the applicant met the applicable requirements for approval. The evidence established that the position was genuine, the nominee performed duties consistent with the nominated occupation, the employment conditions met the relevant requirements, and the applicable labour market testing requirements had been satisfied.

What This Case Shows

The case demonstrated the importance of presenting clear and consistent evidence about the genuine nature of the position, the business activities of the employer and the nominee’s qualifications, experience and actual duties.

For employers facing concerns about the genuineness of a nominated position, the evidence supporting the role can be an important part of addressing the Department’s concerns.

This historical case also demonstrates how a nomination refusal may be reviewed where review rights are available. The appropriate review pathway, eligibility and applicable time limits depend on the decision and the circumstances of the case.

For current Subclass 482 nominations, the applicable requirements differ from those considered in this historical case. Under the current framework, the Minister must be satisfied that the position associated with the nominated occupation is genuine and full-time, subject to the applicable provisions.

If you are facing a visa nomination refusal or considering a Tribunal review, Solve Migration can assess your circumstances and provide guidance on the available options.

Book a Consultation

https://solvemigration.com/book-an-appointment/

Email

ask@solvemigration.com

The right evidence and a clear explanation of the position helped demonstrate why this nomination met the requirements, so does your refusal decision contain evidence or issues that need to be addressed?

 

Book an appointment